The Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 (CARO 2020) is a statutory reporting order issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) specifying matters that auditors must report on in their audit reports.

To which companies does CARO 2020 apply?

It applies to all companies—including foreign companies—except private limited companies below specified thresholds (e.g. paid-up capital ≤ ₹1 Crore, borrowings ≤ ₹1 Crore, revenue ≤ ₹10 Crore).

What is the inventory reporting limit under CARO Clause (ii)?

Auditors must report whether physical verification of inventory has been conducted at reasonable intervals, and whether discrepancies of **10% or more** in aggregate for each class of inventory were identified and adjusted.

What does Clause (ix) require regarding loan defaults?

Auditors must report whether the company has defaulted in repayment of loans or other borrowings to any lender, detailing the lender name, principal, interest, and days of delay.

How does Tally's Audit Trail assist in CARO compliance?

Tally Prime's Edit Log feature tracks voucher modifications (user details and timestamps), helping auditors verify internal controls u/s Clause (xxi).

CARO 2020 Compliance Checklist: Auditor Guide

Statutory audits of Indian companies require compliance with the **Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 (CARO 2020)**. Issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, CARO 2020 expands the auditor's reporting responsibilities to include inventory verifications, asset records, and loan defaults.

Establishing a structured **CARO 2020 compliance checklist** is essential to prepare ledgers and avoid reporting flags.

1. Key CARO 2020 Clauses and Audit Checks

Auditors must report on several critical areas under CARO 2020:

CARO Clause	Reporting Subject	Auditor Verification Requirement
Clause (i)	Property, Plant and Equipment (PPE) & Intangibles	Verify title deeds of immovable properties and maintenance of records
Clause (ii)	Inventory physical verification & Working Capital limits	Audit physical stock verification and report discrepancies \(\ge 10\%\)
Clause (iii)	Investments, Guarantees, Loans given	Report whether terms are prejudicial to company interests
Clause (vii)	Statutory Dues compliance	Report undisputed statutory dues outstanding for over 6 months

2. Management Disagreements and Auditor Qualifications

When auditors identify reportable matters u/s CARO 2020, disagreements can arise. For instance, if an auditor intends to report a default in bank loan repayments u/s Clause (ix) that the company attributes to a processing delay, the management may dispute the qualification.

To manage disputes, auditors document communications, verify bank correspondence, and check that the management's explanation is noted in the final audit report, ensuring balanced disclosures.

3. Case Study: Inventory Discrepancy under Clause (ii)(a)

During an annual audit of a trading company, the auditor reviews physical stock records:

Ledger Stock Balance: ₹1,50,00,000
Physical Stock Value: ₹1,38,00,000
Difference Value: ₹12,00,000 (8.0% discrepancy)
Auditor Action: Because the discrepancy (8%) is below the **10%** statutory reporting limit specified in Clause (ii)(a), the auditor does not report a CARO exception. However, they verify that the company has adjusted the ₹12,00,000 difference in their books, debiting the stock valuation loss to the Profit & Loss account.

4. Forensic Verification of Benami Property Holdings

Under Clause (i)(e) of CARO 2020, auditors must report whether any proceedings have been initiated against the company for holding benami property under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988.

Auditors run forensic searches on public records, check legal expense ledgers for active litigation disclosures, and obtain written management representations to verify compliance.

5. Clause (vii) Statutory Dues Verification

Clause (vii) requires auditors to report on the regularity of statutory dues deposits (such as GST, Provident Fund, ESIC, Income Tax, and Customs Duty).

Auditors compile a list of undisputed dues that remained outstanding for more than **six months** from the date they became payable (for example, March statutory dues unpaid by September 30). These outstanding balances must be disclosed in the audit report.

6. Audit Trail and Internal Controls (Clause xxi)

Under Section 143(3)(j) of the Companies Act read with CARO rules, auditors review the company's internal financial controls. Companies must maintain software with an edit log feature (audit trail) that tracks voucher alterations.

Auditors verify that the audit trail was enabled throughout the year, check that no unauthorized user modifications occurred, and report any system bypasses.

Stop typing invoices manually into Tally: Skip the manual data entry. Just upload your purchase bill PDFs or images, review the extracted values, and sync them directly to Tally Prime in a few clicks with TrulyInvoice. Keep your books audit-ready without the typing.